diff --git a/ajax/getcard.php b/ajax/getcard.php
index e0fb361..781c4aa 100644
--- a/ajax/getcard.php
+++ b/ajax/getcard.php
@@ -13,8 +13,8 @@ $second = false;
 if ( isset($_REQUEST["second"]) && ($_REQUEST["second"] == "true") ) $second = true;
 $initialcard = false;
 if ( isset($_REQUEST["initialcard"]) && ($_REQUEST["initialcard"] == "true") ) $initialcard = true;
-$skip = false;
-if ( isset($_REQUEST["skip"]) && ($_REQUEST["skip"] == "true") ) $skip = true;
+$replace = false;
+if ( isset($_REQUEST["replace"]) && ($_REQUEST["replace"] == "true") ) $replace = true;
 $reverse = false;
 if ( isset($_REQUEST["reverse"]) && ($_REQUEST["reverse"] == "true") ) $reverse = true;
 
@@ -50,6 +50,30 @@ if ( $random_image === false ) {
     sendResponse();
 }
 
+// If we are replacing a card set the previous card to unplayed,
+// set the replacement card to played, then immediately send the response
+if ( $replace ) {
+    if ( $initialcard ) {
+        $data["error"] = true;
+        $data["message"] = "Replacement card requested when no card present";
+        sendResponse();
+    }
+    $last_cardlist_index = array_key_last($_SESSION['cardlist']);
+    $last_played_index = array_key_last($_SESSION['cardlist'][$last_cardlist_index]);
+    $_SESSION['cardlist'][$last_cardlist_index][$last_played_index]->setPlayed(false);
+    $_SESSION['cardlist'][$last_cardlist_index][$last_played_index]->save();
+    $random_image->setPlayed(true);
+    $random_image->save();
+    $_SESSION['cardlist'][$last_cardlist_index][$last_played_index] = $random_image;
+    $data['cards'] = $_SESSION['cardlist'][$last_cardlist_index];
+    $data['cardcount'] = $_SESSION['cardcount'];
+    sendResponse();
+}
+
+// Always increment the card count unless it's the first card request
+if ( !$initialcard ) $_SESSION['cardcount']++;
+$data['cardcount'] = $_SESSION['cardcount'];
+
 $new_cards = [];
 if ( $second ) {
     $new_cards[] = $previous_cards[0];
@@ -57,13 +81,8 @@ if ( $second ) {
 $new_cards[] = $random_image;
 $_SESSION['cardlist'][] = $new_cards;
 $data['cards'] = $new_cards;
-
-if ( !$skip && !$initialcard ) $_SESSION['cardcount']++;
-if ( !$skip ) {
-    $random_image->setPlayed(true);
-    $random_image->save();
-}
-$data['cardcount'] = $_SESSION['cardcount'];
+$random_image->setPlayed(true);
+$random_image->save();
 
 sendResponse();
 
diff --git a/js/main.js b/js/main.js
index c0181c8..498701c 100644
--- a/js/main.js
+++ b/js/main.js
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 var resetting = false;
 var initialCard = true;
-var skipCard = false;
+var replaceCard = false;
 var showingSecondCard = false;
 const audioDice = new Audio("audio/dice.mp3");
 const PREVIOUS = true;
@@ -28,7 +28,8 @@ $(document).ready(function() {
   $("#mana_sun_img").on("click", function() { rollDice(); });
   $("#mana_water_img").on("click", function() { $(".diceroll").addClass("hidden"); });
   $("#mana_fire_img").on("click", function() {
-    skipCard = true;
+    if ( initialCard ) return;
+    replaceCard = true;
     getCard();
   });
   $("#mana_tree_img").on("click", function() { window.open("manage.php", "_blank"); });
@@ -75,7 +76,7 @@ function resetPage(count = 0) {
       $(".diceroll").addClass("hidden");
       resetting = false;
       initialCard = true;
-      skipCard = false;
+      replaceCard = false;
       showingSecondCard = false;
       if ( !initialReset ) {
         showCardCount(data.cardcount);
@@ -138,12 +139,12 @@ function getCard(reverse = false) {
     data: {
        second: showingSecondCard,
        initialcard: initialCard,
-       skip: skipCard,
+       replace: replaceCard,
        reverse: reverse
     },
     dataType: 'json',
     success: function(data, stat, jqo) {
-      skipCard = false;
+      replaceCard = false;
       if ( data.error ) {
          $("#firstimg").attr("src", "");
          $("#secondimg").attr("src", "");